For Keeps cake

 

INGREDIENTS

125 grams butter
½ cup sugar
2 egg yolks
1½ cups plain flour
4 25g can pineapple pieces or
crushed pineapple
1 ½ cups milk
1 cup sugar
½ cup custard powder
300 millilitres cream
1 can peaches (optional)
crushed peanuts (optional)

METHOD

Preheat the oven to 180°C. Grease the base and sides of a pie dish, or ovenproof dish.

In a large bowl, beat the butter and ½ cup of sugar, stir in the egg yolks, and mix well.

Gradually add in the flour, then knead the mixture in the bowl with your hands until it comes together.

Turn mix out onto the bench and knead lightly to a smooth dough that doesn’t stick to your hands.

Break the dough into pieces and, starting at the rim of the dish, press the dough onto the sides and base until completely covered.

Use the back of a spoon to smooth the dough out as best you can and prick all over with a fork.

Bake for 30 to 35 minutes or until golden brown.

Pour pineapple into a sieve over a bowl, collecting the juice. If using pineapple pieces, crush lightly with a masher to make chunks smaller.

Measure the juice and add enough water to make 1½ cups.

Add liquid to a large saucepan, and heat with 1 cup of milk and ½ cup of sugar. Stir and bring to the boil.

In a small mixing bowl, combine the custard powder and the remaining milk, and mix until smooth.

When the liquid has boiled, reduce the heat and whisk in the custard mixture, stirring continuously until it starts to thicken.

Add the drained pineapple and stir. Simmer, stirring until the mixture is thick.

Pour into the baked case and, once cool, chill in the fridge until set.

To serve, whip the cream and spread thickly over the top. Decorate with canned
peaches and/or crushed peanuts.

For Keeps cover

Edited extract and recipes from For Keeps: Recipes Worth Keeping from Chatham Island Kitchens written and published by Chatham Island Netball Club, 2024. Hardback, $40.

This extract featured in our Ngahuru Autumn Edition 2025. 

Related Stories

Black doris plum pie with a scoop of icecream

Black Doris Plum, Coconut & White Chocolate Pie

This pie is the perfect mix of contrasting textures and flavours - sweet and tart, soft and crunchy.

Read More
Drawing of a popsicle

Breakfast Popsicles

Perfect when you’re running late for school and don’t have time to sit down and eat breakfast.

Read More
The Old Way Sweet Scrolls

The Old Way Sweet Scrolls Recipe

Super easy, soft and delicious, these sweet scrolls can be rolled up with whatever flavour combinations you fancy!

Read More

Gorgeous Blackberry & Apple Galette

Galette for one? Why not! Small quantities of homemade pastry are quick to make and so gratifying.

Read More

Out Now

Twenty-Sixth Edition

Our beautiful Takurua Winter 2026 Edition is out now.

Do you have a story to tell?

We'd love to hear it.